The Staggering Cost of Giving Violent Criminals Endless Second Chances

November 17, 2026

The Chicago Tribune worries about the cost of incarcerating repeat offenders. What about the cost of releasing them to terrorize innocent citizens, destroy neighborhoods, and drive taxpayers out of Chicago?

One of the more remarkable characteristics of Chicago’s progressive political establishment is its seemingly inexhaustible supply of sympathy for criminals, accompanied by a rather conspicuous shortage of sympathy for their victims.

That’s a staggering amount of money, particularly for a city and state whose political leadership never seems to have enough of it.

But the Tribune’s treatment of this problem raises an obvious question that somehow receives remarkably little attention: What about the cost of the crimes themselves?

What about the people who were robbed, beaten, shot, terrorized, or murdered? What about the families who lost loved ones? What about the businesses that closed, the property values that suffered, and the residents who packed their belongings and moved someplace where they could walk down the street without fearing for their lives?

And what about the tax dollars that departed with them?

Apparently, those costs are considerably less interesting than the plight of people who find themselves repeatedly incarcerated.

The Tribune reports that researchers examined 28,715 formerly incarcerated individuals associated with North Lawndale and identified a remarkable 92 percent recidivism rate. That figure alone should set off alarm bells throughout the criminal justice establishment — raising serious questions about whether the existing system is accomplishing its objectives.

The Tribune’s answer, predictably, emphasizes rehabilitation, employment opportunities, and the barriers that former prisoners encounter when they attempt to reenter society.

There is an enormous elephant in the room. Some people belong in prison, and some belong there for a very long time. Not because society is cruel. Not because rehabilitation is undesirable. But because the primary obligation of government is to protect innocent people from those who would prey upon them. That elementary principle seems to have been lost somewhere between Springfield, the Cook County criminal courts, and the offices of Chicago’s progressive politicians.

The forgotten purpose of incarceration

Criminal punishment traditionally serves several purposes: Retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, and incapacitation. 

That last word deserves particular attention. Incapacitation means preventing dangerous criminals from committing additional crimes against the public by removing them from society. It is not a complicated concept. A violent offender serving a lengthy prison sentence cannot roam Chicago’s streets assaulting pedestrians, robbing businesses, or shooting at his neighbors. He may remain a danger within prison, and incarceration certainly imposes costs. But the public is protected from his freedom to commit another street crime.

Yet much of the contemporary debate seems to proceed from the assumption that the overriding objective of criminal justice should be returning offenders to the community as quickly as possible. This is arguably a reasonable objective for many nonviolent offenders, particularly those whose crimes arise from addiction, immaturity, or circumstances that can realistically be addressed through treatment, education, and employment. However, it is an entirely different proposition when dealing with habitual violent criminals who have demonstrated, repeatedly, that they represent a continuing danger to society. Some may also suffer from serious psychiatric disorders. Where mental illness is involved, appropriate treatment and lawful secure confinement may be necessary. But criminal violence and mental illness are not synonymous, and dangerousness must be established through conduct and evidence, not labels. For offenders who repeatedly commit serious acts of violence, the criminal justice system should be considerably less interested in providing them with another opportunity and considerably more interested in preventing another person from becoming a victim.

The revolving door has victims. Consider the fundamental absurdity of a system in which someone with a history of serious violent offenses is arrested, prosecuted, released, and subsequently accused or convicted of yet another violent crime. Each time the process repeats, the public pays. Police officers investigate. Prosecutors prepare cases. Judges conduct hearings. Public defenders provide representation. Correctional facilities process defendants. Hospitals treat victims. Insurance companies absorb claims and pass the costs along to policyholders. And, of course, the victims themselves pay a price that cannot be measured in dollars.

The Tribune’s article offers the inspiring story of a woman who emerged from nearly a quarter-century of incarceration, rebuilt her life, obtained employment, and established a cleaning business. Good for her. That’s precisely the kind of successful reintegration that society should encourage. But her story does not establish that every repeat offender represents a similarly promising candidate for rehabilitation. Indeed, it illustrates why distinctions matter. A woman rebuilding her life after incarceration is not interchangeable with a habitual armed robber, a repeat gun offender, or someone who repeatedly commits aggravated battery. Treating these profoundly different categories as though they present the same public-policy problem is not compassion. It is confusion.

The North Lawndale Employment Network deserves credit for helping people establish productive lives. According to the Tribune, only four percent of participants employed through its Sweet Beginnings enterprise returned to prison during the study period. That is encouraging and saves the taxpayers the cost of criminal justice. But it doesn’t follow that the same results can be achieved with every criminal population. Participants selected for employment programs may differ substantially from habitual violent offenders in motivation, criminal history, risk, and willingness to change. Before declaring victory, we ought to know whether comparable offenders receiving comparable services achieve comparable results. And we certainly shouldn’t use the success of one program to justify releasing people who present a demonstrable and continuing threat to public safety.

The enormous cost nobody wants to count

The Tribune cites an estimated annual incarceration cost of $45,000 per prisoner in Illinois, compared with $9,000 to $14,000 for certain employment and rehabilitation programs. That sounds like an excellent bargain — at first glance. Why spend $45,000 locking someone up when we can spend $14,000 helping him find employment? But that’s the wrong comparison when the individual in question is a dangerous repeat violent offender. The relevant comparison is between the cost of incarceration and the full expected cost of releasing someone who may commit additional serious crimes.

How much does a shooting cost? Start with emergency medical services, trauma surgery, hospitalization, rehabilitation, lost wages, disability payments, police investigations, and criminal proceedings. Then consider the human suffering. The permanently disabled victim. The children who grow up without a parent. The family that abandons its home because it no longer feels safe. And if the victim dies, what dollar figure should we assign to a human life? Economists and government agencies estimate the social costs of crime, including losses that extend far beyond government expenditures. A serious violent offense can impose costs that dwarf the annual expense of incarceration.

That doesn’t mean every offender should receive a life sentence. It means that any credible economic analysis of criminal justice must account for crimes prevented through incapacitation, as well as the financial costs of imprisonment. Otherwise, we’re counting the cost of the lock while ignoring the damage caused when the door swings open.

The latest example comes courtesy of a Chicago Tribune piece examining the enormous cost of recidivism in North Lawndale, one of the city’s long-suffering West Side communities. The article cites a University of Illinois Chicago Great Cities Institute study estimating that repeated incarceration associated with North Lawndale has cost Illinois taxpayers more than $1 billion over roughly two decades.

There is another cost that deserves far more attention, particularly in Chicago. People leave. They leave neighborhoods where they no longer feel safe. They leave communities where businesses are reluctant to invest, where insurance costs rise, and where parents worry about their children walking to school. Some move to safer Chicago neighborhoods. Others leave the city altogether, taking their purchasing power, property-tax contributions, and economic activity with them. The consequences can become self-reinforcing. As households and businesses depart, commercial corridors weaken. Vacant properties multiply. The tax base erodes. Remaining residents face diminished opportunities and, potentially, a greater burden supporting public services.

Of course, crime is not the only reason people leave Chicago. Taxes, schools, employment, housing costs, and family circumstances all matter. But it would be absurd to pretend that public safety has nothing to do with residential and business decisions. And the people least able to escape are often the very people progressive politicians claim to champion.

Affluent residents can move to the suburbs or relocate elsewhere. Low-income families may lack the resources to leave dangerous neighborhoods. They remain behind to endure the consequences of policies devised by politicians who rarely have to live with those consequences themselves. This is the ultimate irony of Chicago’s progressive approach to criminal justice. In the name of compassion for offenders, it risks abandoning the innocent residents who most desperately need protection. Rehabilitation and public safety are not mutually exclusive

None of this is an argument against rehabilitation. Quite the contrary. The North Lawndale Employment Network’s efforts to provide job training, employment, and practical assistance are commendable. If those programs help former offenders become productive, law-abiding citizens, taxpayers should welcome the results. But rehabilitation must be pursued intelligently. For nonviolent offenders and those who present manageable risks, alternatives to incarceration may be both humane and economical. For individuals with a demonstrated pattern of serious violence, lengthy incarceration may be the only reliable way to protect the community. Sentences must remain proportionate, lawful, and subject to appropriate judicial safeguards, but protecting the public is not an optional consideration.

The distinction should be obvious. Unfortunately, it is frequently obscured by a political culture that seems more concerned with the supposed injustice of incarcerating criminals than with the actual injustice suffered by their victims. The Tribune quotes Michelle Alexander, author of The New Jim Crow, describing the difficulties former prisoners experience after release as a permanent cage with invisible bars. That is an evocative metaphor.

But there are people in North Lawndale and elsewhere in Chicago who live behind very real bars: the security gates on their windows, the reinforced doors on their businesses, and the fences surrounding homes where families fear what might happen outside. They haven’t committed any crimes. Yet they are the ones living in fear. Who deserves our compassion? The criminals or the victims?

The Tribune concludes with an appeal to recognize the dignity and sacredness of every human life. On that point, we agree wholeheartedly. But the dignity and sacredness of human life do not begin and end with the offender. They extend to the store clerk facing an armed robber, the elderly pedestrian assaulted on the sidewalk, the child struck by a stray bullet, and the hardworking family struggling to maintain a decent life in a dangerous neighborhood. They extend to the taxpayers whose money finances a criminal justice system that ought to be protecting them. And they extend to the countless residents who have concluded that Chicago is no longer a place where they can safely raise their families.

The Tribune is right that recidivism imposes enormous costs on society. But its analysis is incomplete without considering whether excessive leniency toward habitual violent offenders contributes to those costs. The answer is not to abandon rehabilitation. It is to stop confusing rehabilitation with an unlimited entitlement to another chance at the public’s expense.

The purpose of criminal justice is not simply to reduce the number of people behind bars. It is to reduce the number of innocent people victimized by criminals. And until Chicago’s political establishment understands that distinction, the city will continue paying a terrible price — not merely in dollars, but in destroyed lives, abandoned neighborhoods, and the departure of the very taxpayers upon whom its future depends.

Related Posts

SUBSCRIBE