Is Alexi Giannoulias, like Brandon Johnson, placing the interests of illegal aliens ahead of citizens, with potentially fatal consequences?
Another Illinois secretary of state, another deadly truck accident, and another driver’s licensing controversy. What does the record reveal about the man seeking to replace Brandon Johnson?
Illinois politics has a peculiar way of repeating itself, seldom in ways that inspire confidence in government. Consider the parallels between former Republican Governor George Ryan and Democratic Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias, now seeking to become Chicago’s next mayor. Both men presided over driver’s licensing operations that became embroiled in serious controversy. Both controversies involved commercial truck drivers whose qualifications or eligibility came under scrutiny. Both became associated with horrific highway accidents that claimed innocent lives. And both raise a fundamental question: What happens when political considerations take precedence over the public safety responsibilities of elected officials?
The differences are substantial, particularly because Ryan’s involved proven criminal corruption while Giannoulias' involves disputed licensing practices and an ongoing federal investigation. Nevertheless, the similarities warrant attention, especially from Chicago voters contemplating whether Giannoulias represents a meaningful policy alternative to Brandon Johnson.
To appreciate the comparison, we must revisit one of the most disgraceful chapters in Illinois political history. On November 8, 1994, a truck traveling on Interstate 94 in Wisconsin lost a large metal component that struck a minivan carrying the family of the Rev. Scott Willis. The resulting fire killed all six Willis children. The truck driver, Ricardo Guzman, had obtained his commercial driver’s license through an Illinois licensing operation subsequently exposed as corrupt. Investigators discovered employees of the Illinois Secretary of State’s office had been accepting bribes to issue commercial licenses to unqualified drivers, with proceeds helping finance political activities associated with George Ryan, then secretary of state. The resulting federal investigation, Operation Safe Road, uncovered an extensive corruption network that eventually brought down Ryan himself. Convicted of federal corruption charges in 2006, the former governor was sentenced to six-and-a-half years in prison. The tragedy became an enduring illustration of what can happen when government treats commercial driver’s licensing as something other than a solemn public safety responsibility.
Fast-forward 32 years to November 9, 2026, when another Illinois-licensed truck driver was involved in a horrific highway tragedy, this time in Kansas City, Missouri. According to prosecutors, 39-year-old Eldar Skander drove his tractor-trailer into stopped traffic at high speed, killing 35-year-old Olga Sorbalo and her two young sons, Luis and Samir. Their father and three-year-old brother survived, but the youngest child was hospitalized. A family traveling together toward the airport was destroyed in seconds. Investigators reportedly discovered an electronic tablet open to YouTube in the truck, although whether distraction contributed to the collision remains under investigation. Skander now faces three counts of first-degree involuntary manslaughter. And once again, the Illinois Secretary of State’s office is facing questions about how a commercial truck driver obtained his license.
This time, the accusations come from the highest levels of the federal government. In a statement posted on X, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the Department of Homeland Security had identified Skander as a Ukrainian national unlawfully present in the United States, who had been released into the country under President Joe Biden in 2023. Duffy also stated Skander had obtained a non-domiciled commercial driver’s license from Illinois in March 2025, during Giannoulias’ tenure as secretary of state. Duffy announced that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) had launched an investigation into both the trucking company employing Skander and Illinois’s issuance of his license. Duffy called the deaths preventable and promised consequences.
Missouri Governor Mike Kehoe also demanded that Governor J.B. Pritzker review Illinois’s licensing procedures. The question for Giannoulias is whether his office properly verified Skander’s eligibility and qualifications before issuing a license to operate a potentially deadly 80,000-pound vehicle.
Federal regulators had already warned Illinois about deficiencies in its commercial licensing program. Earlier this year, FMCSA notified the Illinois Secretary of State’s office that a 2025 audit of non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses had uncovered substantial noncompliance with federal requirements. According to the agency, Illinois had failed to institute adequate controls to ensure applicants possessed the necessary documentation establishing eligibility. Federal officials reported nearly 20 percent of the licenses examined were issued contrary to federal requirements, including cases involving inadequate verification of lawful presence or licenses extending beyond authorized periods. The agency warned that Illinois could lose approximately $128 million in federal highway funding unless corrective action was taken. Giannoulias disputed the findings, arguing regulators had failed to account properly for extensions of employment authorization documents. That disagreement requires resolution, but the federal findings raise questions about his administration’s oversight.
The scale of the program makes those questions more urgent. According to figures cited in the controversy, Illinois has issued more than 10,000 non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses since 2023, when Giannoulias assumed office. That is a substantial number of drivers entrusted with operating some of the largest vehicles on American highways. It does not mean those drivers were unqualified or unlawfully licensed. But if the federal government’s findings are correct, the state was issuing thousands of credentials through a system with inadequate eligibility controls. How many licenses were improperly issued? How many remain valid? What corrective measures have been implemented? And was Skander’s license among those issued without adequate verification? These questions require answers. Chicago’s mainstream news media also owes the public an explanation for the apparent lack of attention to this controversy, given the serious questions it raises about licensing safeguards and the potential risks to motorists in Chicago and throughout the nation.
Giannoulias’ approach to immigration-related licensing deserves additional scrutiny as expanding access to driver’s licenses for undocumented immigrants has been one of his political priorities. In 2023, working with Pritzker and Democratic legislators, he championed legislation replacing Illinois’s Temporary Visitor Driver’s Licenses with standard four-year licenses bearing the designation “Federal Limits Apply.” The change took effect in July 2024. Giannoulias argued the previous licenses stigmatized immigrants and discouraged some drivers from obtaining insurance and undergoing testing. Supporters contend that licensing people who would otherwise drive without authorization improves road safety, an argument that deserves consideration. The ordinary-license program and the commercial-license controversy are legally distinct, and neither establishes that the other is unsafe. Politically, however, they illustrate Giannoulias’ commitment to accommodating immigrants, including those whose presence in the country is unauthorized. The question is whether that commitment has been accompanied by sufficiently rigorous oversight.
This is where the George Ryan analogy becomes revealing. Ryan’s administration allowed political fundraising and personal enrichment to contaminate a system intended to protect motorists. The potential parallel lies in administrative priorities and accountability. George Ryan’s administration compromised public safety in pursuit of political money. The question now confronting Alexi Giannoulias is whether his administration has compromised licensing safeguards in pursuit of political ideology. The motives may differ, but the public is entitled to demand equally rigorous accountability. Whether that criticism ultimately proves justified will depend on the evidence, including the complete records surrounding Skander’s license. Chicago voters should not have to wait for another tragedy before demanding answers.
And that brings us to the forthcoming Chicago mayoral election. Giannoulias is seeking to replace Brandon Johnson, whose administration has faced criticism over progressive initiatives, including its handling of Chicago’s migrant crisis. Johnson’s sanctuary-city policies and expenditures on migrant housing and services have provoked controversy, particularly among residents of predominantly Democratic neighborhoods who believe their own communities have been neglected. Chicagoans who have spent years pleading for better policing, safer streets, functioning schools, and basic municipal services have reason to question a government that mobilizes substantial resources for newly arrived migrants while struggling to meet longstanding obligations to existing residents. The objection is not to immigrants as human beings. It is to the priorities and tradeoffs of government.
Giannoulias’ candidacy raises questions for those voters. He has attracted support from labor organizations that previously backed Johnson, suggesting a changing political alignment. But changing the occupant of the mayor’s office is not necessarily the same thing as changing municipal policy. On immigration, Giannoulias’ record suggests sympathy for some of the progressive assumptions guiding Johnson. Whether he would maintain, modify, or abandon Chicago’s sanctuary policies remains a question he should answer directly. He may propose different administrative practices or priorities, but voters need specifics rather than assumptions about continuity or change.
There is also a broader lesson about the difference between compassion and responsibility. Government officials frequently defend immigration accommodations as expressions of humanity, inclusion, and fairness. Those are legitimate objectives when pursued within a framework of lawful and accountable government. But compassion for one group cannot excuse indifference to the safety and interests of another. Commercial licensing standards exist because an improperly qualified driver operating an 80,000-pound tractor-trailer can kill an entire family in seconds. Federal eligibility requirements exist for reasons state officials must respect. Municipal sanctuary policies also deserve public scrutiny when residents question their costs and consequences. Government has an obligation to protect the public and faithfully administer laws. The federal audit, the reported issuance of more than 10,000 non-domiciled commercial licenses, and the terrible deaths in Kansas City demand answers.
Before Chicago voters consider Giannoulias for mayor, they should insist on a full accounting of his licensing practices and a clear explanation of how his immigration policies would differ from Brandon Johnson’s. Illinois has already learned, at a terrible cost, what can happen when government licensing safeguards fail. We should not need to learn that lesson twice.
Featured image: “Alexi Giannoulias” by WBEZ, CC BY-NC 2.0

