A sharp rebuke by voters signals a new dawn for CPS
Nearly four years ago, the Chicago Teachers Union (CTU) stood at the pinnacle of its power. At the time of Brandon Johnson’s election as mayor, the teacher’s union controlled dozens of lawmakers in the chambers of the Chicago City Council, the Illinois General Assembly and their reach extended to Capitol Hill. A political organization with an inexhaustible desire to exercise untrammeled power, CORE leadership saw the creation of the Board of Education as the next step to controlling the levers of power over Chicago’s public schools. In 2024, Mayor Brandon Johnson’s appointment of 10 Board members and Sean Harden as president occurring alongside the election of four CTU-backed candidates seemed to solidify CTU’s arbitrary, autocratic power over CPS.
However, the Blue wave which swept across America’s fruited plain on Election Day, November 3rd, navigated around Chicago’s Board of Education elections. In a remarkable triumph for residents and CPS students, the elections saw CTU’s grip over the Board loosened and reduced to a minority. A historic victory, the rebuke voters delivered at the ballot box is a signal Chicago voters had become exasperated with CTU’s noxious influence over Chicago's public schools and up in arms over how CTU generated needless turmoil and demoralization in city government. More importantly, the Board of Education elections offer a chance — if new Board members seize it — to begin repairing Chicago’s public schools.
CTU’s defeat at the polls was hardly shocking. In the three-and-a-half years prior to the elections, CTU had established quite a losing streak: In 2024, the tax referendum, Bring Chicago Home, was defeated, the union was sued the same year over its refusal to release annual Audit Reports, and CORE leadership’s bid to raise dues to drum up capital — a whopping $8.5 million for political purposes — was overwhelmingly rejected by membership. Aggravating matters, public opinion polls taken since 2024 consistently revealed declining faith in both the CTU and its leader, Stacy Davis Gates. Worse, ahead of Election Day, a poll commissioned by the Urban Center suggested Jessica Biggs would rout CTU’s flawed candidate for Board president, Hilario Dominguez.
While the CTU had endured a string of defeats since placing Johnson in office, its loss of control over the Board is a fairly comprehensive repudiation of the union. Above all, this was an election defined by the miserable state of public education in Chicago. Though CTU has long promised to pull its weight to improve student outcomes, the conditions at CPS — poor student proficiency, chronic truancy, safety concerns — continued to flourish due almost entirely to the union’s heavy leverage over the Board. To an astounding degree, the Chicago Teachers Union laid the groundwork of its own reckoning.
Now with a Board of Education liberated from the CTU, the new Board, and its new president, have an opportunity to take Chicago’s public schools in a direction which is most advantageous for Chicago’s students. For the new Board to best serve Chicago, it must ultimately govern with a semblance of responsibility. This is to say, Jessica Biggs must transform herself into a dignified president who can supply agile and enlightened leadership over the Board.
Biggs can first deliver leadership by committing herself to abiding by Board bylaws. Under Sean Harden, the past two years have witnessed policy shaped and budgets adopted only through the interference, influence, and direction of the CTU. Biggs must reverse CTU’s practice of skirting Board rules. She can accomplish this task by clearly articulating she intends to govern through the committee structure as the exclusive source of policy recommendations codified in Board bylaws.
Secondly, to win the trust of the public, the new Board must put an end to the routine budget gamesmanship, exercise fiscal discipline, and pass balanced budgets. When the matter at hand is as daunting in its scope as reforming a CPS’ budget, the first step in reining in spending begins with gutting CPS’ central and regional offices of bureaucratic bloat. By CPS’ own admission, the district has hired nearly 10,000 new employees since 2019. During the same period, CPS has lost a startling 45,000 pupils. Part of a troubling pattern in Chicago’s public schools — CPS recorded another drop of over 11,000 in enrollment for the 2026-27 school year — despite a shrinking student population, no cuts have occurred in a district which employs nearly 22,000 non-teaching staff. A substantial downsizing at CPS is long overdue.
Thirdly, aside from the demand to issue layoff notices, the repurposing of underenrolled or unused school buildings should take priority. Today, 255 CPS buildings operate below ideal capacity by a staggering 70 percent capacity. Worse, nearly 50 schools in CPS remain open though they operate at one-third capacity; and nearly a dozen more high schools are open despite functioning at 20 percent capacity. The time has come for the Board to finally, and mercifully, close, combine, or lease some CPS buildings. Though closures are likely to cause considerable consternation at the CTU Center, a modest attempt to close or consolidate underenrolled schools would save CPS over $100 million, perhaps more.
Although the CTU would be willing to wage war in the streets to prevent these closures, the new Board has significant leverage over the union: The moratorium on school closures expires in 2027. Though the CTU bloc on the Board could attempt to pass an 11th-hour measure to extend the moratorium, any action preventing school closures could be undone in January by the incoming Board.
Moreover, to maximize opportunities to save, outside closures and consolidations, the Board would best serve Chicago to consider leasing CPS property to the city’s 100 charter schools. Today, thanks in part to the meddlesome CTU, charter schools are almost entirely shut out of CPS property. By developing a policy which leases serviceable buildings to charter schools, CPS would take in revenue from charter networks.
Fourthly, the Board has the rare opportunity to reverse the CTU’s offensive to dismantle select enrollment (SE), magnet and charter schools. Part of the CTU’s campaign to dissolve school choice and replace it with a “one-size-fits-all” Sustainable Community School model (SCS), the SCS network backed by the union has been revealed to be a failure, with evidence showing proficiency rates among students enrolled in SCS schools lagging behind district averages, higher spending on SCS, and a drop in enrollment in SCS schools. More troubling, the SCS system in which the union has placed blind faith relies heavily on services provided by local non-profit organizations with deep ties to the CTU. Though it is doubtful the new Board will approve the expansion of charter schools, at minimum, members must maintain SE, magnet, and charters. Most importantly, the Board is compelled to boost funding for charters, which has been deprived of proper resourcing through the machinations of the CTU.
Last, as the new Board assumes its leadership role, part of its urgent work should also include an overhaul of curriculum to replace the “knowledge-free zones” which have developed in classrooms. A mission of paramount importance, the Board should scrap sham programs, the purpose of which is to turn children into champions of “social justice.” In place of the “progressive education” philosophy desired by the CTU, the Board should adopt coherent, grade-by-grade curriculum, which is essential for citizenship in our ethnically diverse democracy. A return to the basics, the curriculum should restore knowledge in the classrooms and emphasize direct instruction of the reading, writing, and arithmetic skills necessary for pupils to rewarding careers and success in life.
Though the new Board of Education has an opportunity to recommit public schools to educating students, one unwelcome obstacle remains: The Chicago Teachers Union. Though the union was rebuffed, it was not defeated. Over the past two years, the Harden-led Board overindulged the teacher’s union, to which the CTU habitually used its influence to skirt rules and cross sacrosanct lines to satiate their desires and force the Board to genuflect to its wishes.
Between 2024 and 2026, the CTU maneuvered to dismiss former CEO Pedro Martinez, escalated budgets, and define policy with remarkable success. In sum, Sean Harden granted CTU leadership effective veto power over Board policy. Though now reduced to a minority presence on the Board, the CTU is still a formidable foe with which the incoming Board must contend. Already, CTU’s jilted leadership is lashing out, with the irascible Davis Gates grudgingly reminding the public on election night walking a picket line is one weapon lurking in her arsenal.
The CTU has given the new Board a window into how it intends to coexist with its opponents now it no longer holds a supermajority. Rather than seek out areas in which interests align, the CTU bloc is certain to reject the role of good-faith cohort for the benefit of pupils and will indubitably play the bad-faith actor, running an insurgent campaign to undermine Board business and, if needed, create a circus atmosphere, or engage in open revolt for the purpose of disrupting proceedings. In the absence of any spirit of cooperation from the CTU-aligned bloc, Biggs and the new majority should not exert themselves to cement a coalition with the Board’s CTU faction.
With the CTU promising to be a malignant problem even in the minority, Jessica Biggs and the independent bloc would be wise to shun the CTU bloc altogether. An intractably hostile political foe, the CTU’s goals do not intersect with the independent bloc and are utterly incompatible with the objective of returning CPS to centers of learning and raising student outcomes. As the new Board is seated, rather than attempt to end any estrangement with the CTU bloc, Biggs and new members must be prepared to go it alone.
Residents who voted to banish the Chicago Teachers Union from the Board of Education did so because they had lost trust in the union’s control over the Board. That loss of trust was well earned. It is now up to Jessica Biggs and new Board members to rebuild confidence in the Board of Education. Restoring trust in the Board begins with sensible and sincere reform of Chicago’s public schools. Though only the start in reversing the damage to CPS, if the Board can make progress by stopping the flow of red ink, shuttering underused buildings, reducing bureaucratic bloat, and purging radical curriculum, they will uplift the fortunes of Chicago’s students and earn plaudits from voters.
Though the new Board members will face howls of incensed disapproval from a determined opponent — the CTU — the incoming members must never pale before a difficult decision and never flinch from the responsibility entrusted with them. An independent Board is a decisive moment for Chicago’s public schools. If the new Board delivers on reforming CPS, it will mean the beginning of the end for the Chicago Teachers Union.

