The Republican Midterm Debacle Offers Opportunities for the Center-Right in Chicago

November 19, 2026

Moderate Republicans can win upcoming elections by focusing on issues that affect people where it really counts: their pocketbooks

He’s gone now.

Who is?

President Donald J. Trump. Not really, but his power is diminished.

To use the word Barack Obama chose after the Democrats’ 2010 midterm thumping, the Republican Party received a “shellacking” at both the local and national levels in this month’s elections.

For the most part, the Iran War and the resulting dramatic spike in gasoline prices made “affordability” the mainstay of the Democrats’ successful 2026 campaign message. That and hatred of Donald Trump.

Nevertheless, there is a silver lining for the GOP after its midterm catastrophe.

However, to be fair, President Trump has accomplished many good things, starting with closing the border and enforcing immigration law. Crime is dropping nationwide, and Trump’s border policy likely played a role in that.

The president's political positions, when you look past some of his absurdities, such as his obsession with building monuments, for instance the so-called Arc de Trump, are generally mainstream conservative fare. Besides, the border, Trump supports an aggressive approach to law enforcement, lower taxes, and fewer regulations. The Democrats, particularly in Illinois, are on the opposite side of those issues. The Prairie State is the home of the nation’s only no-cash bail law. According to the Illinois Policy Institute, Pritzker has raised taxes and fees at least 63 times since 2019. As for regulations, a 2024 study by the Mercatus Center found Illinois is the fourth-most regulated state, trailing only California, New York and New Jersey.

Crime pays because everyone pays for it

Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson is a dimwitted leftist hack whose record has been defined by ideology over results. He once described the Defund the Police movement as “a political goal.” 

Crime is expensive, particularly theft. Unpunished shoplifting drives up prices. Retailers who are compelled to hire their own security pass that expense on to consumers. Some store owners give up fighting shoplifting, so they close. Fewer retailers means less competition and higher prices. 

Insurance claims for shoplifting and flash mob lootings are not “free.”

After campaigning against property tax increases, a year after his election Mayor Johnson proposed raising them. Fortunately, the City Council unanimously shot that down.

Statewide, Illinois consistently ranks second among the states in property tax burden. That’s not affordable at all. 

It’s Trump’s fault even when it isn’t

Chicago voters, in recent statewide races and local contests, occasionally are given the choice of a center-right candidate who vows to fight back against these unpopular and expensive political positions. Especially when that candidate is a Republican, they are immediately linked to Trump by leftists.

And it’s not just Republicans. Even though Chicago Board of Education races are non-partisan, a PAC heavily funded by the Chicago Teachers Union still produced a mailer tying Jessica Biggs, a candidate for Board president the CTU opposed, to Trump.

Biggs, who won her race, describes herself as a progressive Democrat.

Center-right Chicagoans, when discussing a conservative candidate for office with a friend or relative who is politically to their left, almost always receives a response along these lines:

“But...but...Trump!”

During the gubernatorial campaign, Pritzker mentioned Trump more than he did his Republican opponent, Darren Bailey.

Donald Trump is president for 26 more months, but his imprint on the domestic political scene will wane. He will probably focus his efforts, as Ronald Reagan did after the Democrats won control of the Senate in 1986, on international affairs. That may not be a bad thing for America and the world, because 10 months after the Gipper left office, the Berlin Wall fell, and two years later the Soviet Union collapsed.

Orange Man gone is an exaggeration, but Orange Man fading is not.

The permanent campaign

Yes, I know, it is still 2026, but the left has been on permanent DEFCON 1 alert campaign status since at least the Barack Obama presidency; if our side is going to successfully challenge them, we must follow suit. Eleven months after next year’s municipal runoff elections the 2028 primary elections take place.

And as you discuss politics within your circle of friends and on social media, you will likely find attempts to sway others a bit easier now that the “But...but...Trump” rejoinder is less potent.

Center-right candidates in Chicago, or for county or states offices, won’t have to answer for Trump either.

Especially since the main issue Democrats ran on this year was affordability. As Trump did in 2024 -- that obviously didn’t work out for him.

Democratic governance is not affordable

But the Democrats will soon learn that affordability is a slender potato chip to base political power on, especially since their policies drive costs higher.

Pritzker, when he presumably runs for president, will have to answer — if the media does its job, even half-heartedly — for those 63 tax and fee hikes, as well as Illinois having the nation’s second-highest gasoline tax.

Despite Pritzker’s incessant boasts about credit upgrades, Illinois still has the lowest credit rating of any state in the nation — making it more expensive for the state to borrow.

Why stop at 63 tax hikes? As for the gasoline tax, it is tied to the inflation rate. It will always go up in Illinois, just as the sun does every morning.

After signing a public transit funding bill in August, Chicago’s sales tax rate on general merchandise increased to 10.5 percent — which is one of the highest in the country.

Affordability is a foreign concept to most Chicago public officials. For example, most recent “affordable” housing developments cost more than $500,000 per unit to build, with several exceeding $800,000. Over-regulation is frequently cited as the cause, but graft and incompetence should never be ruled out as a cause of Chicago's failures. One such housing project includes two electric vehicle charging stations — amenities that make no sense in dwellings intended for lower-income residents, given that EVs themselves remain expensive and largely out of reach for the people the units are supposedly meant to serve.

Chicago dipped a toe into the rent control rathole with the anti-gentrification Northwest Side Housing Preservation Ordinance, which went into effect last year. It is not pure rent control, which is banned under state law, but the result will likely be the same. Eventually it will mean less housing — and higher rents.

And of course, the General Assembly can repeal the anti-rent control law. They certainly have the votes, thanks to their strong midterm performance and partisan gerrymandering.

On those infrequent occasions when reporters question Pritzker about Illinois’ high property taxes, he brushes them off, saying rates are set locally. That is not entirely accurate. In 2017, a statewide property tax freeze bill backed by his predecessor, Republican Bruce Rauner, failed to pass the Democrat-controlled General Assembly.

Darren Bailey supported a one-percent cap on property taxes, but the governor dismissed that proposal as impractical. But Indiana has such a cap on primary residences. Many other states have similar safeguards against property tax hikes.

On the flipside, those $800,000 affordable housing units in Chicago need to be paid for by taxpayers, many of whom are financially just getting by for reasons already discussed in this article and more.

Welcome to Chicago, where your property taxes have more staying power than your property

The media, however, loves a sob story. Once in a while they cover soaring property taxes but they nearly always omit key context — such as Illinois’ lack of a statewide property-tax bill cap and the state’s ranking among the highest property-tax rates in the nation. 

Here is what NBC Chicago said recently: 

“Property taxes topped the list of costs Chicago-area residents want lowered, according to a recent, unscientific NBC 5 Responds survey of more than 1,200 people. Nearly 27 percent said housing costs led them to consider moving out of their community in the past year."

‍

History shows this is not a new problem for Chicago.

What does the local center-right need to do?

Pound the left on the affordability issue and then take it from there. 

Tell your friends all about it. Make new friends too. 

There is a city and a state in need of a turnaround.

And the left, to paraphrase what Richard Nixon said in a concession speech, won’t have Donald Trump to kick around for much longer.

Related Posts

SUBSCRIBE