Mayor Brandon Johnson’s Shotspotter Shell Game

November 20, 2026

With 72 percent of Chicago voters demanding the return of gunshot detection technology, the mayor resorts to political rope-a-dope, promising action while delivering nothing but delay

Muhammad Ali famously employed a boxing strategy he called “rope-a-dope,” leaning against the ropes, absorbing his opponent’s punches, and waiting for him to exhaust himself before striking back. Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson appears to have adopted a political variation of that strategy as he approaches the February 2027 mayoral election, hoping to survive an increasingly uncomfortable confrontation over his decision to dismantle the city’s ShotSpotter gunshot detection system.

Having made opposition to ShotSpotter a centerpiece of his political identity, Johnson now finds himself confronted by a City Council that wants the technology restored and an electorate that has just delivered an unmistakable verdict on the subject. More than 72 percent of Chicago voters supported a nonbinding referendum calling for the restoration of gunshot detection technology. The mayor’s response? A bureaucratic shell game involving vaguely defined pilot programs, unidentified vendors, shifting procurement procedures, and promises that seem to evaporate almost as soon as they are made. The objective, one suspects, is not to restore gunshot detection technology but to run out the political clock while pretending to do something about it.

The latest installment of this municipal comedy unfolded during City Council hearings on Johnson’s proposed 2027 budget, when Chief Procurement Officer Sharla Roberts informed incredulous aldermen that the administration was abandoning its previously announced plan to begin testing a replacement gunshot detection system in early November. That pilot, promised just weeks earlier, was supposed to demonstrate that the administration was finally getting serious about replacing the technology Johnson had decommissioned in September 2024. Instead, Roberts announced the city would pursue a broader evaluation involving multiple vendors, without offering much clarity about when testing would begin or how it would proceed. Alderman Samantha Nugent accused Roberts of obstruction, pointing out that she had failed to attend an earlier committee hearing, substituted a letter promising a pilot within two weeks, and then failed to deliver. Even Alderman Jason Ervin (28), a Johnson ally, was sufficiently baffled by Roberts’ explanation to ask: “What does that mean in English?” It is a question that might reasonably be directed at the entire Johnson administration.

What makes this episode particularly revealing is that the administration’s sudden change of direction followed legal pressure from SoundThinking, the company that operates ShotSpotter. Its attorneys had advised the city that any pilot conducted as part of the procurement process would have to include all shortlisted vendors, including SoundThinking itself. In other words, the administration apparently could not conduct its preferred experiment while excluding the very technology whose elimination had created the controversy in the first place. Whether that legal intervention actually prompted the change remains uncertain, but the timing certainly invites scrutiny. Meanwhile, even interim Police Superintendent Fred Waller appeared to know little about the original pilot. That is a remarkable state of affairs. The police department is supposed to be the principal beneficiary of this technology, yet its top official apparently was not sufficiently informed about the program to explain it to the City Council. One wonders who, exactly, is running this operation and whether anybody has any intention of bringing it to a conclusion.

Nor can the administration plausibly claim that this is some brand-new technological frontier requiring years of exploration. Chicago operated ShotSpotter for years before Johnson shut it down. The city subsequently solicited proposals from companies interested in providing replacement technology, and nine firms submitted formal bids in 2025. The last two city budgets reportedly allocated a combined $13.9 million for replacement technology, with another $5 million contemplated in the latest budget. Yet here we are, more than two years after the system was switched off, still talking about preliminary testing, procurement procedures, and the possibility of yet another pilot program. At some point, due diligence ceases to look like diligence and begins to resemble deliberate paralysis. The taxpayers are entitled to ask what all this money and administrative activity have accomplished, beyond providing the mayor with another excuse for not making a decision.

There is a larger issue here that ought not to be lost amid the bureaucratic maneuvering. ShotSpotter was never merely a device for telling police officers where somebody fired a gun. Its advocates argue that it provides a means of identifying concentrations of gunfire, directing police resources toward areas where shootings are occurring, helping investigators locate evidence, and, perhaps most importantly, dispatching police officers and emergency medical personnel to shooting victims who might otherwise remain undiscovered until somebody calls 911.

Consider a victim lying wounded in an alley or on a deserted street, unable to reach a telephone or summon assistance. In such circumstances, the difference between an automated alert and waiting for a witness to call the police could conceivably be the difference between life and death. This does not establish that every ShotSpotter alert saves a life, or even that the technology consistently improves outcomes. Those are questions that deserve careful measurement. But they are also questions that should have been answered before the mayor eliminated an existing public safety tool without having a replacement ready.

Critics of ShotSpotter raise legitimate questions about false alerts, unnecessary police deployments, cost, privacy, and the possibility that the technology contributes to excessive policing in neighborhoods already experiencing strained relationships with law enforcement. Those objections should be examined rather than dismissed. But they must also be weighed against the consequences of failing to detect actual gunfire. A false alert can waste police resources; an undetected shooting can leave a wounded human being without assistance. Neither outcome is acceptable, and a competent administration should be capable of evaluating both.

Furthermore, there is nothing inherently contradictory about demanding rigorous performance standards while continuing to employ a technology that may provide important benefits. The reasonable course would have been to establish measurable criteria for accuracy, response times, investigative usefulness, and medical outcomes, then determine whether ShotSpotter or a competitor could satisfy them. Instead, Johnson removed the existing system first and left Chicago waiting for an alternative that remains perpetually just over the horizon.

Then there is the inconvenient matter of democracy. On November 3rd, Chicago voters were asked whether the city should restart the use of gunshot detection technology that informs first responders when gunshots are detected. More than 447,000 voters answered "yes," representing roughly 72 percent of those voting on the question. That is not a narrow victory or an ambiguous mandate. It is an overwhelming expression of public preference on a specific municipal policy. Granted, the referendum was advisory rather than binding, and it did not explicitly endorse ShotSpotter over competing products. But it certainly did not endorse indefinite bureaucratic delay. Johnson and his political allies are fond of invoking the will of the people when it supports their agenda. Now that the people have spoken on a matter where their wishes conflict with the mayor’s ideological preferences, their voices appear to have become considerably less compelling.

Johnson’s predicament is understandable from a political standpoint, even if his response is not defensible from an administrative one. He came into office promising to dismantle what he and his progressive supporters considered an overly aggressive and ineffective approach to policing. ShotSpotter became a convenient symbol of that philosophy, an expensive piece of technology he derided as a “walkie-talkie on a stick.” Reversing course would require him to acknowledge the issue is more complicated than his campaign rhetoric suggested. But refusing to reverse course puts him at odds with many aldermen and a substantial majority of voters. Hence the shell game: support gunshot detection technology in principle, condemn the existing technology in practice, promise to investigate alternatives, and then keep investigating until the election is safely behind him. It is a clever political maneuver, assuming the electorate is sufficiently inattentive to fall for it.

The mayor also points to declining shootings and homicides as evidence that his public safety investments are working. We should all welcome those declines, whatever their causes. But this argument is a non sequitur. The fact fewer people are being shot does not mean that technology capable of detecting shootings has become unnecessary. By that reasoning, a decline in house fires would justify dismantling the fire alarm system. Nor does a statistical crime reduction establish that the elimination of ShotSpotter contributed to the improvement. Crime trends reflect many factors, and attributing them to a single mayoral policy without persuasive evidence is political self-congratulation masquerading as analysis. The relevant question is whether effective gunshot detection can improve the police department’s response to the violent crimes that continue to occur, regardless of whether their overall frequency is rising or falling.

Chicago’s citizens deserve something considerably better than this elaborate exercise in political evasion. The administration should publish a firm schedule for testing competing technologies, disclose the standards by which they will be judged, involve the police department directly in the evaluation, and commit to a date for making a decision. The City Council should insist upon regular public reporting and refuse to accept another procession of missed deadlines and unintelligible explanations. If ShotSpotter proves superior, restore it. If a competitor offers better performance at a reasonable price, choose the competitor. If the evidence demonstrates that none of these systems delivers sufficient value, explain that conclusion openly and defend it before the voters. What is unacceptable is pretending that an endless evaluation process constitutes a public-safety policy.

Ultimately, this controversy is about more than ShotSpotter. It is about whether Chicago’s government exists to serve the practical needs of its citizens or to preserve the ideological purity and political fortunes of its elected officials. Johnson has every right to believe ShotSpotter was a mistake. He does not have the right to substitute bureaucratic gamesmanship for competent government, particularly when public safety is at stake.

Muhammad Ali’s rope-a-dope strategy worked because he eventually came off the ropes and delivered the punches that won the fight. Johnson seems content to remain against the ropes indefinitely, hoping the voters will tire of asking questions. But this is not a prizefight, and the stakes are not a championship belt. They are the lives and safety of Chicagoans. The mayor needs to stop playing games and start governing.

Related Posts

SUBSCRIBE